Honduras News Archives: negotiations

Zelaya Accepts No “Agreement” Returning Him to the Presidency of Honduras

The following is an interpretation and translation of an article appearing in the Honduran Newspaper, “El Heraldo”. The original article (spanish) can be read here.

A solitary Manuel Zelaya, a refugee without power in an embassy of another country, has decided he will not comply with the agreement that his own delegates signed.

The former president confirmed his position in a letter full of spelling errors and inconsistencies, which was sent yesterday to President Barack Obama, who he accused in several paragraphs, of furthering the crisis in Honduras.

In truth, Zelaya had been clear in stating repeatedly that he would respect any agreement reached among the Honduran dialogue. Thus, the negotiating teams of Manuel Zelaya and Roberto Micheletti on October 30th, signed the Tegucigalpa-San José Agreement.

This agreement provides in paragraph 5, the most important, that the National Congress could roll back the Honduran government to the state it was in before June 28th.

Although the proposal, that Congress was to decide upon his reinstatement or not, came from the same commission representing Zelaya, including Mayra Mejia, Rodil Rivera and Victor Meza, Zelaya decided after signing the agreement, not to fulfill it. Including the part that he would help form a Government of National Unity and Reconciliation. This government was to be formed on November 5th, but that was not possible because Zelaya refused to send a list of 10 candidates for positions in the unity government. This decision left an uneasy feeling within the international community, which saw that the former president was defying the agreement. Zelaya then decided to remove his deputy, Jorge Arturo Reina, from discussions with the Verification Commission, despite the fact it was precisely the commission’s role to help negotiate differences that might arise surrounding the implementation of the agreement.

Thomas Shannon, Assistant Secretary of State in the U.S., and leading advocate of signing the agreement, confirmed, a day after signing the document, that the formation of the unity government had nothing to do with the possible reinstatement of Zelaya to the presidency. Zelaya protested Shannon’s statements, and requested in a letter addressed to Hillary Clinton, to clarify whether the U.S. had changed its position on what happened in Honduras on June 28th. The State Department replied that the U.S. position remained the same, however, they emphasized that they would respect the agreement that was reached by both parties.

Following the signing of the Tegucigalpa – San José Agreement, several countries announced the immediate dispatch of election observation missions to oversee the elections of November 29th. Zelaya, however, began to make calls from the Brazilian Embassy to boycott the elections, contrary to the spirit of the agreement, which provides for unrestricted support of the elections.

In his letter to Obama, Zelaya basically says the Tegucigalpa-San José Agreement was invalidated, because the 12 points were not to be followed independent of each other. Therefore, Zelaya now believes he is not willing nor obliged to meet any of the remaining 12 points, including in the electoral process.

Despite calls from Zelaya not to support the election process, several countries have decided to support the democratic journey.

The EU announced it would not send an electoral mission only due to the lack of time, but did confirm they would send two experts on electoral issues to help with the process. Colombia returned its ambassador and announced that Sonia Pereira recognizes the elections. Also, the President of Panama announced yesterday that they will recognize the elections and the newly elected president thereafter.

José Miguel Insulza, however, despite being the Secretary of the OAS and guarantor of the agreement, ruled out sending observers for the electoral mission. Insulza had stated on many occasions that he would respect any decision they made in Honduras. The decision that followed, was that both parties would accept the resolution of Congress.

Some lawmakers complained that they received threatening messages, but warned that democracy and the fight against corruption has a price, and therefore would decide on his possible reinstatement on the basis of law. The committees of Zelaya and Micheletti had both acknowledged that Congress would be the ultimate expression of the representation of the people.

As if this were not enough, Zelaya has begun to lose his main strongholds in the media. The former Zelaya supporter, Eduardo Maldonado, decided to come aboard the democratic ship and declared the elections “are legal”. Zelaya is now lonely, abandoned by his “friends”, with 18 indictments for crimes against corrupt politicians, powerless, and relegated to staying inside the Brazilian embassy, where he has been since Sept. 21st.

So ends the sad story of a man who tried to illegally implement a fixed consultation, not imagining that a whole people, along with brave military leaders committed to the country, would hinder his attempt to abuse and destroy the Constitution, the state of law, and the democratic system.

“I do not accept any agreement that returns me to the Presidency.”

In his letter to Barack Obama, former President Manuel Zelaya declares: This election is illegal because it hides the military coup, and the de facto state Honduras is living in provides no guarantees of equality and liberty in public participation …

… In my capacity as President, elected by the people of Honduras, I reaffirm my decision that from this date forward, whatever the case, I do not accept any agreement to return to the presidency. Zelaya Statue Will Not Be Displayed Afterall

Zelaya’s Letter to Obama – Rough English Translation

PRESIDENCY OF THE REPUBLIC Determined Zelaya
From the Desk of
Mr President

Tegucigalpa, November 14, 2009

S. E.
BARACK OBAMA
U.S. PRESIDENT
Washington D. C.

Dear President Obama:

When we met for the first time on July 8 with the Secretary of State
Clinton after the coup was left clear to me and to the world the
Obama administration’s position of condemning the coup,
unaware of their authorities and demand the return of the rule of law with the
refund for President elected by the people. The official position of his
government and their representatives who sponsored and signed resolutions
UN, OAS. In the third point that requires my immediate and safe return.

As of June 28, 2009 my abduction by the military and exile
Costa Rica. The Congress of the Republic issued a decree ordering illegal where
“Separating the citizen José Manuel Zelaya of the office of President
Constitution of the Republic “no constitutional powers to do so, and
without due process without being summoned to a trial.

Since the first meeting with Secretary Hillary Clinton I proposed the
mediation of President Oscar Arias of Costa Rica even though I consider
it is counterproductive to dialogue with people who have a gun in their
hands, accept U.S. recital sponsored and community
internationally.

In a statement dated 04 September this year the Secretary of
State Hillary Clinton expressed the following: “The successful conclusion of
process initiated by Arias would be the basis for proceeding with a
legitimate choice ”

It is well known that the de facto regime without a visit to Honduras by sub.
Secretary of State for Western Hemisphere Affairs Thomas Shannon, Daniel

Restrepo and Craig Kelly had not signed the Agreement. We all know that
broke the agreement, Tegucigalpa – San José.

President Oscar Arias himself for the sake of truth declare that “Micheletti
never had that will to cooperate and instead was making fun
international community and sought only to delay the time to never
deliver power where it belongs. ”

Former President Ricardo Lagos, a prominent member of the Commission
International Verification statements confirm this by stating:
“The Lord Micheletti broke”, “Micheletti did things he should not have
made as to say I’ll form a unity government without Zelaya “what
caused the failure of this negotiated agreement.

The very day it was installed in Tegucigalpa, the Credentials Committee, the
agreement struck by the statements of officials of the Department of
State in which change their position and interpret the agreement unilaterally
with the following statements “… the elections would be recognized by
United States with or without a refund … “The de facto regime welcome this
change and used these statements to their objectives, and immediately
terminated for violating and violating the agreement

Because of that we express as follows

That the Agreement Tegucigalpa-San Jose is without value or effect on
unilateral breach of the de facto government. This was conceived
to be implemented comprehensively and simultaneously, as no
looked like twelve separate agreements, one agreement was with
twelve points which had a single purpose, to restore order
democracy and social peace, and this would reverse the coup,
which means the safe return of elected President of Republic
legitimately by popular vote. And so, foster a climate of
national reconciliation and a subsequent constitutional electoral process,
clean, with guaranteed free and equal participation for all
Citizens of Honduras.

* That the next election will be developed within a framework of
legality and international support especially from the OAS and UN
and that outside these political and citizenship rights
minimum to ensure an outcome attached to liberty and
transparency. In this, I note that the new staff position
United States Government’s initial target elusive dialogue
San Jose, relegating an agreement with the government legitimately
recognized into the background and trying to move this agreement
to a new electoral process regardless of the conditions under which
develop. Among others, public resources are being authorized
by public officials not legally recognized and charged to a
Budget document has not been authorized by President
legitimately recognized.

Under these conditions, this process, and therefore their results will
not subject to challenge and recognition, which seriously jeopardizes
the future stability of relations between Honduras and the rest of
nations to recognize its results.

As noted by the OAS Secretary General Jose Miguel Insulza, not
There is a political environment for elections, as has been observed and pointed
U.S. Congresswoman Jane Sharkorky during his visit to Honduras,
observes an environment proven violation of human rights
Honduras.

On 6 November, we reported our refusal to continue with
false dialogue, and so the expiry is check point
dead that is losing relevance, because an agreement is met in a timely manner,
violation of this by the de facto regime is for us the condition
determines that the agreement ceased to exist.

Undoubtedly precious time was lost in this attempt.

The presidential election is currently scheduled for the last week of
November. In this case, as Constitutional President of Honduras, as
representing citizen and was elected by democratic vote of the people of
Honduras, I feel obliged to report that under these conditions
We can support and to challenge legally on behalf of
Thousands of Hondurans and hundreds of candidates who feel that this
competition is uneven and there are no conditions for participation in
freedom.

* In Honduras for the repression that people today are subjected
Honduras, where it is observed or the highest authority of the President
Republic, which has not been considered in three years I managed the
better economic indicators and the largest poverty reduction
of the 28 years of democracy, which was overthrown by force
weapons, was never subjected to a trial or due process and I
today, 24 indictments and arrest warrants for drug trafficking and corruption
terrorism among others, and where most of the ministers of my
cabinet are subjected to political persecution and are fleeing the
regime in different parts of America.

* 3,500 people detained in one hundred days, over 600 people injured and
beaten in hospitals, more than a hundred murders and a
Countless numbers of people subjected to torture committed against
citizens who dare to challenge and express their ideas,
freedom and justice, peaceful demonstrations, all this makes the
November elections in an undemocratic exercise of state
illegitimacy, by uncertainty and military intimidation, for large
sectors of our people.

* Carry out elections, in which the President elected by the people of
Honduras, who recognized his government and the international community,
is a prisoner, surrounded by soldiers in the embassy of Brazil, and
a president of Facto, who imposed the military, surrounded by the
powerful in the government palace, will be a historical embarrassment to
Honduras and a disgrace to the democratic people of America.

* This election is illegal because it hides the coup
military and de facto state in Honduras living provides no guarantees
equality and freedom in civic participation at all Hondurans,
is an undemocratic electoral maneuver repudiated by major
sections of the people to cover up the perpetrators and masterminds
the coup d’etat.

* Elections are a process not just a day where you choose, it is
discussion, is exposition of ideas is equal opportunity.

* In my capacity as President elected by the Honduran people, I reaffirm
my decision after that date, whatever the case,
I do not accept, any agreement to return to the presidency, to
disguising the coup, we know to have a direct impact
by military repression on human rights of the inhabitants of
our country.

Mr. President.

At the Summit of the Americas Countries held in Trinidad and
Tobago earlier this year, where I present you said

“What we fail to denounce America for what he did in the past
on the continent and we saw toward the future. ” The future before us
shown to alter its position in the case of Honduras and so encourage
improper intervention of the military caste in the civic life of our State,
(historical cause of the backwardness and stagnation of our countries in the twentieth century)
It is but the twilight of freedom and an insult to human dignity, is
a new war against the processes of social and democratic reforms as
necessary in Honduras.

President Obama.

Whenever you overthrow a legitimately elected Government in America
violence and terrorism, we win a battle and Democracy suffers a defeat.

We still refuse to believe that the military coup underway in
Honduras is now the new, state terrorism of the twenty-first century. And will the future
Latin America we speak in Trinidad and Tobago

We are firmly determined to fight for our democracy without obscuring the truth
and when people decide to fight peacefully for their ideas, no
weapon, no army can stop or maneuver.

I await your prompt response, I reiterate my highest consideration,

José Manuel Zelaya Rosales
President of Honduras

Zelaya’s Letter to Obama (Spanish)

PRESIDENCIA DE LA REPUBLICA

Del Escritorio de Señor Presidente

Tegucigalpa, 14 de Noviembre de 2009

S. E.
BARACK OBAMA
PRESIDENTE EEUU
Washington D. C.

Estimado Presidente Obama:

Cuando nos reunimos por primera vez el 8 de julio con la Secretaria de Estado Clinton después del Golpe de Estado se dejo claro ante mi y ante el mundo la posición de la administración Obama de condenar el Golpe de Estado, desconocer sus autoridades y exigir el retorno del estado de derecho con la restitución, al cargo de Presidente electo por el pueblo.

La posición oficial de su gobierno y sus representantes que patrocinaron y firmaron las resoluciones de la ONU, OEA. En el que el tercer punto exige mi restitución inmediata y segura. A partir del 28 de junio de 2009 mi secuestro por los militares y destierro a Costa Rica. El Congreso de la República emitió un decreto ilegal donde ordena “Separar al ciudadano José Manuel Zelaya del cargo de Presidente Constitucional de la República” sin facultades constitucionales para hacerlo, y sin el debido procesos sin ser citado a ningún juicio.

Desde la primera reunión con la secretaria Hillary Clinton me propusieron la mediación del Presidente de Costa Rica Oscar Arias a pesar de que considero que es contraproducente dialogar con personas que tienen un arma en sus manos, acepte considerando el auspicio de EE.UU y de la comunidad internacional.

En un comunicado de fecha 04 de septiembre del presente ano la Secretaria de Estado Hillary Clinton expresaba a lo siguiente: “La conclusión positiva del proceso iniciado por Arias sería la base adecuada para proceder con una elección legítima”

De todos es conocido que el Régimen de Facto sin la visita a Honduras del sub. Secretario de Estado para el Hemisferio Occidental, Thomas Shannon, Daniel Restrepo y Craig Kelly no hubieran firmado el Acuerdo. Todos sabemos por que se rompió el acuerdo, Tegucigalpa – San José.

El propio Presidente Oscar Arias en aras de la verdad declaro que: “Micheletti nunca tuvo voluntad de colaborar y que por el contrario se estaba burlando de la comunidad internacional y sólo buscaba dilatar el tiempo para nunca entregar el poder a quien corresponde.” .

El Ex Presidente Ricardo Lagos, miembro prominente de la Comisión
Internacional de Verificación en sus declaraciones confirmo esto, al manifestar:
“El Señor Micheletti lo rompió”, “Micheletti hizo cosas que no debía haber hecho como decir yo formare un gobierno de unidad sin Zelaya” lo que hizo fracasar este acuerdo negociado.

El propio día en que se instalaba en Tegucigalpa la Comisión de Verificación, del acuerdo sorprendieron las declaraciones, de funcionarios del Departamento de Estado donde modifican su posición e interpretan el acuerdo unilateralmente con las declaraciones siguientes “…las elecciones serían reconocidas por Estados Unidos con o sin restitución…”; El régimen de facto celebro este cambio y utilizaron estas declaraciones para sus objetivos, e inmediatamente terminaron por incumplir y violar el Acuerdo

Por lo anteriormente expuesto nos manifestamos de la siguiente manera:

Que el Acuerdo Tegucigalpa-San José queda sin valor ni efecto por
incumplimiento unilateral del gobierno de facto. Este fue concebido
para implementarse en forma integral y simultánea; pues no se
contemplaron como doce acuerdos separados, fue un solo acuerdo con
doce puntos el cual tenía un solo propósito, restaurar el orden
democrático y la paz social, y con esto se revirtiera el golpe de estado, lo que implica el seguro retorno del Presidente de República elegido
legítimamente por voto popular. Y con esto, propiciar un clima de
reconciliación nacional y un siguiente proceso electoral constitucional,
limpio, con garantías de participación igualitaria y libre para todos los
ciudadanos de Honduras

Que las próximas elecciones se debían desarrollar en un marco de
legalidad y respaldo internacional especialmente de la OEA y NNUU
y que fuera de esas condiciones políticas y de derechos ciudadanos
mínimos para garantizar un resultado apegado a la libertad y a la
transparencia.

En esto, quiero anotar que la nueva posición de los funcionarios del
Gobierno de los Estados Unidos esquiva el objetivo inicial del diálogo de
San José, relegando un acuerdo con el Gobierno legítimamente
reconocido hacia un segundo plano, y tratando de trasladar este acuerdo
hacia un nuevo proceso electoral sin importar las condiciones en que se
desarrolle. Entre otras, con recursos públicos están siendo autorizados
por funcionarios públicos no reconocidos legalmente e imputados a un
documento de Presupuesto que no ha sido autorizado por Presidente
legítimamente reconocido.

En estas condiciones, este proceso, y por lo tanto sus resultados serán
sujetos de impugnación y no reconocimiento; lo cual pone en grave riesgo la estabilidad futura de las relaciones entre Honduras y el resto de naciones que reconozcan sus resultados.

Como lo ha señalado el Secretario General de la OEA José Miguel Insulza, no existe un ambiente político, para elecciones, como lo ha observado y apuntado la Congresista Norteamericana Jane Sharkorky en su visita a Honduras, se observa un ambiente comprobado de violación a los derechos humanos en Honduras.

El 6 de noviembre pasado, hemos comunicado nuestra negativa a continuar con el dialogo falso, y por lo tanto al expirarse el plazo el texto constituye letra muerta que pierde vigencia, porque un acuerdo se cumple en tiempo y forma, la violación de este por el régimen de facto es para nosotros la condición que determina que el acuerdo dejo de existir.

Indudablemente se perdió tiempo precioso en este intento fallido.

La elección presidencial esta actualmente prevista para la última semana de noviembre. En este caso, como Presidente Constitucional de Honduras, y como ciudadano que representa y fue elegido por voto democrático del pueblo de Honduras, me veo en la obligación de informar que bajo estas condiciones no podemos respaldarla y procederemos a impugnarlo legalmente en nombre de millares de hondureños y de cientos de candidatos que sienten que esta competencia es desigual y no se presentan las condiciones de participación en libertad.

* En Honduras por la represión a que hoy está sometido el pueblo
Hondureño, donde no se respeta ni la más alta autoridad el Presidente de la Republica, donde no se ha considerado que en tres años logré los
mejores indicadores económicos y la más grande reducción de la pobreza de los 28 años de vida democrática, donde fui derrocado por la fuerza de las armas, nunca fui sometido a un juicio ni al proceso debido y tengo hoy 24 acusaciones y ordenes de captura por narcotráfico corrupción y terrorismo entre otros, y donde la mayor parte de los Ministros de mi gabinete son objeto de persecución política y se encuentran huyendo del régimen en diferentes partes de América.
3500 personas detenidas en cien días, mas de 600 personas heridas y
golpeadas en los hospitales, mas de un centenar de asesinatos y una
incontable cantidad de personas sometidas a torturas cometidas contra
ciudadanos que se atreven a oponerse y manifestar sus ideas, de
libertad y justicia, en manifestaciones pacificas, todo esto convierten las elecciones de noviembre en un ejercicio anti-democrático por estado de ilegitimidad, por la incertidumbre y la intimidación militar, para grandes sectores de nuestro pueblo.

* Realizar elecciones, en las que el Presidente electo por el pueblo de
Honduras, a quien reconoce su Gobierno y la Comunidad Internacional,
está prisionero, rodeado por militares en la sede diplomática de Brasil, y
un Presidente de Facto, que impusieron los militares, rodeado por los
poderosos en el palacio de gobierno, será una vergüenza histórica para
Honduras y una infamia para los pueblos Democráticos de América.

* Este proceso electoral es ilegal porque oculta el golpe de estado
militar, y el estado de facto en que vive Honduras no brinda garantías de igualdad y libertad en la participación ciudadana, a todos los Hondureños, es una maniobra electoral antidemocrática repudiada por grandes sectores del pueblo para encubrir los autores materiales e intelectuales del Golpe de Estado.

* Las Elecciones son un proceso no son solo un día donde se va elegir, es un debate, es exposición de ideas es igualdad de oportunidades.

* En mi condición de Presidente electo por el pueblo Hondureño, reafirmo mi decisión que a partir de esta fecha cualquiera que fuera el caso,

YO NO ACEPTO, ningún acuerdo de retorno a la presidencia, para
encubrir el golpe de estado, que sabemos que tiene un impacto directo
por la represión militar sobre los derechos humanos de las habitantes de
nuestro país.

Sr. Presidente.

En la Cumbre de Países del Continente Americano celebrada en Trinidad y Tobago a principios de este año, donde estuve presente Usted manifestó

“Que dejáramos de acusar a Estados Unidos por lo que hizo en el pasado
en el continente y que viéramos hacia el futuro”. El futuro que hoy nos
muestran al alterar su posición en el caso de Honduras y favorecer así la
intervención abusiva de las castas militares en la vida cívica de nuestro Estado, (causa histórica del atraso y estancamiento de nuestros países en el siglo XX). No es mas que el ocaso de la libertad y un desprecio a la dignidad humana, es una nueva guerra contra los procesos de reformas sociales y democráticas tan necesarios en Honduras.
Presidente Obama.

Cada vez que se derroca un Gobierno legítimamente electo en América la violencia y el terrorismo nos gana una batalla y la Democracia sufre una derrota.

Todavía Nos resistimos a creer que este golpe de estado militar en ejecución en Honduras, es ya el nuevo, terrorismo de estado del siglo XXI. Y será el futuro para América latina que nos hablo en Trinidad y Tobago

Estamos firmes decididos a luchar por nuestra democracia sin ocultar la verdad y cuando un pueblo se decide a luchar pacíficamente por sus ideas, no hay arma, no hay ejército ni maniobra capaz de detenerlo.

En espera de su pronta respuesta, le reitero mi más alta consideración,

JOSE MANUEL ZELAYA ROSALES
Presidente de Honduras